Experiment 39 Comparing Skull Edge and Apocalypse Shaper in PvP

tags: [item modification] [other game mechanics aspects]

so many weapons for your class:
a choice is always wide.
which one to take and use - alas!
is too hard to decide.
thus, to eliminate this lack
completely at this stage,
we made this test:
an r-grade sword or rather a skull edge?​

comparing skull edge and apocalypse shaper in pvp

​

purpose: to compare the efficiency of skull edge - pvp and apocalypse shaper (haste + focus) in pvp.

target: othell adventurer lvl 99 with all skills learned.

equipment: eternal leather set (assassin type / light)

attacker: othell adventurer lvl 99 with all skills learned.

equipment:

{tbody}{tr}{tr}{tr}{tr}{/tr}{/tr}{/tr}{/tr}{/tbody}

eternal leather set (assassin type / light)

skull edge - pvp (critical damage) +4 (weapon's p. atk. = 388)

skull edge - pvp (critical damage) +12 (weapon's p. atk. = 468)

apocalypse shaper (haste + focus) +4 (weapon's p. atk. = 471)

experiment: we will attack the target form behind with normal attack (registering normal and critical damage) and with skills (registering double critical damage) using these daggers.

{tbody}{tr}{tr}{tr}{tr}{/tr}{/tr}{/tr}{/tr}{/tbody}

blood stab

heart breaker

chain blow

reverse

both characters were without buffs.
results:



characters under the effect of elixir of blessing.
results:

​

conclusion: as the tables show, in both cases the critical damage from basic rogue's skills is higher when using a weapon with sutable special ability, even if that weapon's p. atk. is lower.

 

thanks for the test...i know i should ask it somewhere else...but i'll ask anyway :x , can we have the same test but also with specter shaper 2 sa? or just tell us if the damage done by the r95 shaper is higher than the skull one? :x

 

here is test for other weapons:
http://boards.lineage2.com/showthread.php?t=260455

 

2x s.a give you like more 5% in pvp dmg.

 

1sa+pvp gives u same bonus aswell

 

at least someone tested it

 

dont forget about sa haste/focus from r grade its still better then this lol 22 dmg from skull.

 

yeah, i know,but since tauti's test in naia was different...i guess this one may be the same :x

i know , but from tauti p.atk on othell's increase their damage , so since r95 p.atk is higher than r shaper , i was wondering which one was better (since the difference was pretty low , maybe an r95 shaper may land the same or even a little higher damage)