Brooch stones for Yul

I would like to ask about the most appropriate setting stones in 4 slots brooch for Yul

 

Ruby opal diamond pearl for pve
Ruby diamond pearl obsidian for pvp

 

Why Pearl for pve? Opal not better one for it?

 

https://l2wiki.com/La_Vie_En_Rose's_Brooches#List_of_Jewels

 

Hi, what is the chance to make a lvl 5?

 

))

 

I'd go with opal for both pve and pvp..

About chance for lv 5, I think it's 10% chance to go from lv 4 to lv 5, but not sure..

 

Takanodan, you would have a link which shows the chance of each lvl or experiment conducted?

I tested it with 100 box aquamarine and got only one lvl 4

 

I don't know of any experiment.. I said I think might be 10% 'cause I made like 4 brooches lv 5 (3 sapphire) and I think should be around there.. but ofc it's not that reliable..